Wednesday, August 29, 2007

We, The Institutionalized People

The entire western world, from the age of 5 is indoctrinated into the institutionalized society which is the education system. From there, a child will spend the next 13 years in grade school, jumping academic hoops and pleasing their teachers by doing what they want to get good grades. From institution from institution these children progress through, but yet, it is still more of the same-- children are told what to do and are graded on how well they execute their commands. Children, in this light might look like glorified biological computers.

We are told in that point of our lives that we need to get good grades so we can get a good job to live a prosperous and happy life. Such is the dream that we are told and we believe it throughout the majority of our lives. We hear the same comment from everyone, from teachers, parents, adults and friends. It becomes a universal truth, almost like a fundamental one like 1+1=2-- irrefutable, because we know no better. And so, we carry on through grade school, jumping through the hoops, like a circus act, where our biggest performance is a test for entry in to a much larger and extravagant institution otherwise known as University.

We finally get into university and realize a sense of freedom-- we choose our own departments, our own courses and even when to take them from a scheduled list. What incredible freedom, nothing like we had before in our grade school years. But still, it is still more of the same-- marching orders from our professors and academic hoop jumping.

"But this time," as most of us think, "we are going to be free. Freedom, finally."

Anxiety sets in, the year before graduating. "I'm going to graduate! What next!?" We wonder. Obviously our next problem to deal with is getting a job and making money out of the necessity to survive. With little a thought, resumes and cover letters are fired off left right and center to whatever company with an opening. Sooner or later, we find ourselves with a job, following orders and getting evaluated by our bosses.

From cradle to grave, this is how most of us will live, everyday being told what to do and being evaluated. Most of us will probably not realize it because we are probably comfortable with it because it is the only life we know. Most of us will end up taking up a few hobbies along the way and perhaps do some traveling from time to time.

And from time to time you will be asked by new friends, "what do you like doing?" For which most of us will stumble through looking for something to say to make ourselves not look entirely lame; it becomes like a traditional greeting, something that everyone does and not think twice about.

And that is what I think is the biggest travesty of our time.

6 comments:

Sacha said...

I think the 20th century was unprecedented in terms of the amount of "disposable" income (i.e. time) people were given out of the wealth that was created.

As a result a lot of people don't know what to do with this freedom and are uncomfortable having to think about how to use their time to the best extent.

I remember reading proposals to extend the school year to the entire year with a couple two-week vacations interspersed, but I think this is the worst idea imaginable. Any time spent in institutions beyond a certain limit is horribly destructive to creativity.

Unknown said...

The acid test is-- if you had unlimited money, what would you do? Would you still do what you do?

I mean, I would! Even at the worse of times, I wouldn't trade it for any other job =P Of course, I complain about nonsense as much as any other person though =P If I won a innumerable fortune, I would go on doing what a do, showing up at work on time (or just after, more likely) the next day.

The question is, would you?

Unknown said...

Actually, I don't even have many hobbies outside of work...in a way, it's sort of ...disturbing...

Unknown said...

Finally, I am reminded of a M. d'Engle (sp?) novel, in which a character says:

"A sonnet is strictly regulated in its form and syllable construction. Yet what you want to say is entirely up to you."

Working in the institution is not a sizable barrier to being free =P

Lord Metroid said...

Good text if choice for publishing on your blog. Written by John Taylor Gatto if I recall correctly. I totally. Google him and hear his expertise testimonials of what mandatory schooling are doing to our personalities and society.

Great guy in my opinion.

Paladiamors said...

Sacha:

In terms of disposable income, I think that is perhaps one part of the problem. But I think that is the result of coming suddenly to a state of being free after sloging through school and then getting a job.

I think that the problem is that most people have never really been free and have no idea what to do if they were free. That being the case, I would hypothesize that there are many that would be comfortable not being free, since it gives them one less problem to deal with... ironically.

That being the case, you are correct when it comes to a destruction to creativity since most people live their lives being told what to do instead of actively thinking about what they wanted to do. You can't exactly command someone to be "creative".

I do believe that creativity can only exist in a free environment, because it is also necessary to make mistakes along the way to come to a good idea.

Ida:

If you have found the job that you totally love and would even do without for money, then I am incredibly happy for you, that is something that many people have not been able to achieve.

There have been many cases of people winning the lottery and continuing their lifestyle because it is either something they really enjoy doing or it is the lifestyle they have gotten used to that they continue to go to work.

In my case, there is no set job that I find attractive and actually, I would hope that the work I do is more an adventure than just working a job. Building and designing devices and systems to assist people in their work or improving their quality life seems like a lot of fun to me (so long as I am learning lots of cool things along the way).

As per your quote, yes, I agree that there needs to be some structure in the way we do things, like organizations and etc. But the problem is that I think that organizations have been institutionalized so much that it is the only thing that most people see-- "Join this organization.. work this job, climb the ladder, manage underlings and etc."

There are other ways of life, like working freelance or doing a startup working on problems that you find interesting, instead of working in an institution and being told what to do all the time.

I think that is part of the problem in our society. If everyone said something like "when I grow up, I want to work in a big institution and first take orders from a boss and climb the ladder and etc" then I would have no problems with that, but I have a feeling that most people aren't wired like that.

Metroid:

There is also another interesting guy called Ken Robinson about the same thing too.

http://www.ted.com/index.php/talks/view/id/66

check out the above link if you have the time~